Thursday 3rd July 2025

You’d think in an age when travel between many urban centres is booming, not least by passengers pursuing leisure activities, a bus service between Wetherby (population 11,000) and Leeds, its nearest regional centre lying 13 miles south west, would be prime territory for a successful commercial operation.
All the more so as Wetherby is marooned from the rail network making bus the only public transport on offer.

Yet Transdev Blazefield, the current operator of half hourly routes X98/X99 linking the two locations has given notice it’s pulling out from the end of August.

This comes exactly three years after First Bus also pulled out of the route (in August 2022) which led to Transdev Blazefield stepping in to give it a go.

Not only that, the company gave it a fulsome ‘go’ by using its high quality ‘Sky Class’ branded double deck buses with their ‘wow factor’ specification that had previously been used on the Cityzap branded high profile route between York and Leeds which became a Covid casualty.

I took a ride on route X98 in November 2022, a few weeks after these high profile buses made their debut, and it was certainly an impressive experience.

A more memorable couple journeys than when I’d travelled on the route a few years before that in the First Bus era. On both occasions I recall decent numbers of passengers travelling making me think the route had a commercial base.
As I was in Leeds recently I thought I’d take another trip up and down the route to try and reassess its potential.

I caught the 13:35 X98 from the terminus stop in Boar Lane close to Leeds railway station. Buses pick up at two further city centre stops including one close to the bus station and Victoria Centre.
Having negotiated the many sets of traffic lights for pedestrian crossings along Boar Street, Duncan Street and New Market Street we headed out of the city centre at 13:41 with a decent ‘load’ of 27 on board.
Other than one passenger boarding near Scarcroft (about half an hour later and seven miles from Leeds) the journey to Wetherby bus station only saw passengers alighting including roughly a third within the limits of Leeds City and another third at various stops through to Wetherby where we arrived on time at 14:19. Seven, almost the remaining third, were still on board of whom four alighted and three stayed on the bus, with two more joining, for the 16 minute circuit the bus then does of the residential area in north Wetherby reaching Deighton Bar.

After that, the bus returns to the bus station and heads back to Leeds for another journey on the X98.
That happens hourly, while on the opposite ‘half hour‘ from Leeds, an hourly X99 follows a similar route to the X98 as far as Bardsey where it diverts to serve East Keswick taking 53 minutes to reach the bus station in Wetherby instead of the X98’s 44 minutes.
From Wetherby heading south the quicker X98 leaves for Leeds at 45 minutes past the hour with the X99 leaving at 06 minutes past the hour facilitating an even 30 minute gap where the routes meet up from Bardsey into Leeds.

I caught the 15:06 X99 from Wetherby back to Leeds.
The bus arrived from its previous journey on time at 14:58 and a dozen or so passengers alighted which was impressive to see.

There was a changeover of drivers reminding me this route has its logistical challenges for Harrogate based Transdev Blazefield with Wetherby about 10 miles from its base there making driver reliefs a costly proposition.
We left on time with just five on board, picking up three more in Collingham but losing four by Scarcroft. More passengers joined as we hit the Leeds built up area with total passengers for the journey hitting 18 including only two two travelling the whole way.
As you can see the X98 was operated by double deck buses in generic Transdev Blazefield livery and the X99 had single decks wearing the red Harrogate livery.

They’re not bad buses but are a far cry from the Sky Class buses which were removed from the route and transferred to the Burnley area in early 2024.
I suspect regular passengers must be feeling quite despondent after losing their ‘luxury’ buses and now hearing the route is being abandoned by the second commercial operator in three years.
As I always say, making assumptions based on a very small toe in the water sample travelling is always dangerous but these were off peak journeys on a Tuesday and I would have thought there are many more commuters travelling at peak times as well as students and school children.
I’m surprised it hasn’t proved a commercial success and it’ll be interesting to see if another operator comes forward to take it on commercially. I can’t see Arriva doing so as it’s not in its West Yorkshire ‘territorial waters’ but I noticed Wetherby was well served by Connexions and wondered if Craig Temple is eyeing up the opportunity.

However with Mayor Brabin itching to begin ‘taking back control’ with her new Weaver branded network there’s not really any incentive for an operator to take the route over with the inevitable lead time of rebuilding passenger numbers up to the level needed for sustained commercial success.

Why take that risk when the X98/X99 could instead be a trailblazer for the Weaver network and a bus company gain a no risk contract rather than an at risk commercial venture?
Roger French
Summer blogging timetable TThSSu

The only time the word “Cityzap” appeared in my Diary was for a Rail Replacement Service from Surbiton to Walton on Thames. The coach was N588GBW. It was a Dennis Javelin, with Caetano Algarve II bodywork owned by London Country South West aka “Horsham Buses”. [C51Ft].
LikeLike
Remember that the original rail service was abandoned long ago in 1964 by Mr. Beeching. Thought to be non viable then.
LikeLike
Thanks for highlighting the situation in our town, Roger. As Editor of our community newsletter, the Wetherby Free Press at http://www.pkmarketing1.com/wetherby-free-press I have written extensively about the decline of this service. (It’s a great read that highlights a very small-town mentality with little interest in buses but will fight tooth and nail to stop car parking charges – yes, it is still free here, subsidised of course by tax-paying bus users).
In the last Issue 80, there is a timeline showing when regular passengers, like me, did indeed begin to feel ‘despondent’. Wetherby is a wealthy area and we found the reason why they disposed of the Sky Class luxury buses hard to believe – vandalism. And yes, they went to Burnley!
Their replacements were old and unreliable. The 21% more passengers claimed by Transdev in the first year were no doubt lost. We were promised new buses last year and after months of silence they never materialised.
It’s strange that the nearby famous 36 is every 10 minutes but they could not make the X98/99 pay when it is every 30 mins.
First Bus were at least reliable and used only double-deckers. We can only dream that a quality company like Go-Ahead take over the route.
Paul Kirby, Wetherby
LikeLiked by 2 people
Don’t forget the estate scum from the likes of Chapletown and Seacroft board this bus to go to school in Wetherby (bottom of Roundhay Road for the Chapletown idiots and at the stop near Boggart Hill for the Seacroft idiots, apparently local schools in those areas are too rough lol!), seen many a chavvy idiot board the early X98 into Wetherby and the post 4pm bus from Wetherby so yes can believe the vandalism did happen.
LikeLike
It doesn’t excuse vandalism but to write people off with such horrible language is very nasty indeed – I suggest you withdraw your comment.
Stephen
LikeLiked by 3 people
Costs ? I can only assume things like min wage and the NHI increases are factors , Weatherby’s problem is it is just too far from anywhere really
LikeLike
The X98/99 to quite an extent is competing against the service 7 Harrogate, Wetherby Leeds
LikeLike
The 7 is also run by Transdev and does not compete with the X98. It takes a completely different route, is 15 mins longer and is now hourly after Transdev cut it from every 30 mins. Nobody in Wetherby would use the 7 to get to Leeds instead of the X98 (unless they wanted a change of scenery).
LikeLiked by 2 people
Possibly they need to look to reducing it to an hourly service
The early morning journey’s are already a combined x98/99 journey
LikeLike
You would not be able to run an hourly service covering both Deighton Bar and East Keswick with 2 buses, so either parts of the route would see their service degraded to 2-hourly, or you’re halving the core service but only saving 25% of vehicle and driver costs.
LikeLike
Could you run a circular which serves the X98 out and X99 back one hour, then the X99 out and the X98 back the second hour? Then at least every hour you get a service even if you have to go the long way round
LikeLike
That doesn’t work, because the X98 runs beyond Wetherby bus station, so if you run out on the X98 then you have to run back on the X98 as well. The only way you could alternate them would be to have one bus running the X98 backwards and forwards, and one bus running the X99 backwards and forwards.
LikeLike
This situation completely encapsulates why the concept of Franchising is gaining so much traction.
It looks like it’ll be three operators in as many years for a route which, at face value, looks like there’s reasonable passenger demand. Another LA is likely going to have to pick up the tab if no commercial operator steps in. Might as well grasp the nettle and franchise the whole network in one go instead of the drip, drip of not knowing where funding is going to be required next.
In a deregulated environment this can only be seen as market failure, despite some valiant efforts in raising the quality of the offer over the years. Meanwhile, there will the inevitable concerns from the travelling public how they will get to work come September.
Dan Tancock
LikeLike
That increase to the 321 is a shocker. Watford to St Albans is already 4 buses per hour (321, 724, 321, 725), ramping it up to six seems like it will be massively over bused.
LikeLike
The increase in the 321 frequency will be at the expense of the 721, which will be withdrawn. It is expected the St Albans to Hemel via King Harry Lane section of the 721 will become a separate service.
Dan Tancock
LikeLike
If Connexions do take the route on, it will be interesting to see how they go about it – whether they interwork it with school buses, leaving gaps in the morning and afternoon services as they do on some routes, but that doesn’t seem tenable on a long route like this – and as they have a policy of not running in the evenings or on Sundays then presumably WYCA will have to contract those to another operator if they want them to continue.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Note the subtle distinction between “our time will come to an end”/”hand over to a new operator” and “Firstbus stepped away”. Never mind the gentle implication that it’s out of their hands, the current operator joins the previous one in ratting off in exactly the same way.
LikeLike
Clearly the routes in there current form are not viable.
I think an hourly service would be far more viable
LikeLike
The alternative history is that a carefree operator decided to encumber a troubled route with the high costs of new vehicles and it backfired.
Older vehicles are then used to keep costs under control and it just didn’t work out.
Proof that you can’t just paint a bus with nice colours and everything works…
LikeLike
Seems strange that a town only 13 miles from a major regional centre cannot support a quality bus service.
Contrast with Corsham in Wiltshire, pop c 13,000, 9 miles from Bath (the regional centre), three buses per hour weekdays, half hourly Saturdays, hourly Sundays. Service continues to Chippenham, so the Corsham to Chippenham section will be a significant contribution to revenue.
Peter Brown
LikeLiked by 1 person
I doubt that many commenting on these services have ever used them or know anything about them, or the areas that they serve. Someone said that the 7 competes with the X98/9. It doesn’t. It is even slower and takes a totally different route, serving totally different villages on the way. No-one would use it to travel the whole route from Leeds to Wetherby.
HBC took over the service from First probably because there was pressure to find a use for some expensive, needlessly over-specified buses from the failed Zap route. A heated windscreen for the top deck (most cars don’t have those), seat-back reading lights (most with blown bulbs) and cupholders – guaranteed to spill your drink on the X99 route, demonstrates over-enthusiasm for wasting money.
Incidentally, it was the much improved rail service between Leeds and York with fare reductions, and a much faster journey time compared with the bus that took the custom away from Zap.
They probably saw the X98/9 as another 36 style operation. There were all sorts of plans touted and surveys completed, but once the MD was replaced, nothing ever happened. The buses were totally unsuitable for a route with the pinchpoints in Linton and East Keswick. In the early days, so many mirrors were knocked off and the service cancelled as a result. If there was any vandalism, it was mainly to the outside from the terrain. Those buses quickly went and were replaced with a revolving door of old bangers. The breakdown rate has contributed to the downfall of the service. One day last week, there were only 2 buses on the route when there should have been 4.
The speed of the service also contributed to the unpopularity. Under First it was a limited stop and the route changed in Leeds at peak times to avoid the traffic. HBC changed both of those and implemented a crazy timetable that provides for the same journey time at 9pm as at 9am, so there is much time wasted sitting at stops, so the bus doesn’t leave early. The journey time off-peak takes twice that of a car or taxi.
Wetherby is also closer to Harrogate than Leeds, and culturally has much more in common. People are just as likely to shop, and work there. Many children from Wetherby go to Harrogate schools. Only a few from Leeds are bussed into Wetherby for school.
Finally there is the affluence factor. Once beyond the new Leeds orbital road, the whole area is very affluent. Linton is the most expensive village to buy a house in the whole of Yorkshire. There are no stations serving the area, and most people have several cars. Linton Lane is just one multi-million pound house after another. There are not many people standing at the stops that are widely spaced, in a village with no continuous pavement, and no street lights, whilst leaving the Ferrari, and the Bentley and the Range Rover at their mansion, behind the electric gates.
The service will transfer to Connexions. There is no one else, and an announcement has been made that an evening and Sunday operator is being sought, which points clearly to the requirement only for an operator for the times that Connexions do not operate.
The service is also subsidised as it is. Franchising to provide a more regular service cannot be about wasting public money to provide services that no one wants to use.
LikeLike
The contract has been awarded to Go Ahead. Hopefully they will be more reliable, speed the service up, make it limited stop again, and use a timetable and route appropriate to the time of day.
The experimental last service of the day from Wetherby to Bardsey via Linton and East Keswick has been withdrawn as it wasn’t used and funding it was a waste of resources.
LikeLike
is any company taking over the 98 route, wetherby to kirk deighton, back to wetherby, on to Leeds from sept 1st? If so are there any timetables available please
LikeLike
Go-Ahead West Yorkshire will be taking the routes over using the same timetable as now except the 2310 from Wetherby won’t run.
See:
https://www.yorkshireeveningpost.co.uk/news/traffic-and-travel/x98-and-x99-wetherby-service-saved-5235811
LikeLike
That information is now out of date. Taken from the WY Metro website:
X98 X99 Leeds • Collingham • Wetherby • Deighton Bar
Sun 31 Aug 2025
Operated by Harrogate Bus Company (Transdev) / GoAhead West Yorkshire
This service will be taken over by GoAhead West Yorkshire. On weekdays, the 1830
Leeds to Wetherby (X99) will be extended to Deighton Bar, and an additional journey
will operate at 1930 Leeds to Wetherby Bus Station (X99). On Saturdays, the 0600
Leeds to Deighton Bar (X99) will be withdrawn, and the 0842 Deighton Bar to Leeds
(X99) will commence from Wetherby Bus Station at 0905, but additional journeys will
operate at 0834 Deighton Bar to Leeds (X98) and 1805 Leeds to Deighton Bar
(X99). On weekdays and Saturdays, the 2310 from Wetherby to East Keswick and
Collingham (X99) will be withdrawn. Some journeys will be retimed by around 5-15
minutes.
LikeLike