25 Places with two stations: 15 Helensburgh

Saturday 26th July 2025

Welcome to another blog featuring the fourth station pair to be found within a town or city on precisely the same line of longitude but on completely different rail lines (see Canterbury, Yeovil and New Mills, previously featured in this fortnightly series)

But, as you can see from the above map, the ‘separate lines’ serving Helensburgh Central and Helensburgh Upper only diverge from each other just over a mile east, towards Glasgow, by Craigendoran station on the eastern edge of Helensburgh, which although not clear on the map, is only on the line to and from Central.

As its name implies Helensburgh Central (above photo) is located in the heart of the town of Helensburgh on the north bank of the River Clyde while Helensburgh Upper (below photo), is on the famous West Highland Line.

Although the stations are just two thirds of a mile apart, the above photos demonstrate they couldn’t be more different offering the starkest contrasting station pair yet covered in this fortnightly series.

Helensburgh Central obviously sees many more passengers than Helensburgh Upper; indeed about 50 times as many with 626,000 using the station to enter and exit in 2023/24 while Upper saw just 11,700.

But that must be an estimate as, just like at Falkirk, passengers can buy a ticket interchangeable to either station from Glasgow, so the Office of Rail and Road must make some big assumptions to determine those figures.

Obviously the number of train departures is also dramatically different with Central having a half hourly service to Glasgow serving Queen Street Lower Level with trains continuing via Airdre and Bathgate to Edinburgh Waverley which together with trains from Balloch makes for a busy commuter route while Upper sees just a few trains each day on the West Highland Line to Oban, Fort William and Mallaig but does also see the Caledonian Sleeper in the early morning and evening on its way from Euston to Fort William – quite a thing for a small Scottish town the size of Hellensburgh (population 15,610) to have a direct train to London.

All told, Central has 36 train departures and 35 arrivals on weekdays while Upper has six northbound and seven southbound although three of the former split at Crianlarich to either Oban or Mallaig and of course the Sleeper calls at 06:33 northbound and 23:23 southbound.

Helensburgh Central came first, in 1858 thanks to the Glasgow, Dumbarton and Helensburgh Railway with Helensburgh Upper courtesy of the West Highland Railway in 1894.

In its heyday Central probably needed the three terminating platforms it still has now, but with the current half hourly service and trains arriving and departing with a 10 minute or so turn around there’s really only a need for one platform. Indeed the line into the station is only a single track line from the junction where the line heads off to Helensburgh Upper and Crianlarich. The arrangement reminded me a bit of Hertford East.

A large section of the platforms are under a glass roof as is the eastern end…

… and the concourse area making for a very light ambience, especially on a sunny day as when I visited back in May.

On the concourse there’s a rather nice independently run café (thanks Kath) as well as toilets (for ScotRail passengers)…

… and the main exit takes you through to…

… the ticket office with its multiple windows, but I suspect only one is ever in use.

There’s strong evidence the station once had four platforms…

…or perhaps an area for goods trains on the southern side of the station which is now given over to car parking, and at very cheap rates too.

There’s a ticket machine for when the ticket office is closed…

… and a number of redundant looking offices but with a rather nice sign post pointing the way to various highlights in the town.

It’s nice to see a station now clearly under utilised from its past glory but obviously looked after and kept in good condition.

It’s about a fifteen minute walk up the hill to Helensburgh Upper…

… where the station entrance…

… is characterised by a long covered ramp down…

…to the platform on the single track line.

As you can see it’s a delightful setting among the very tall trees and the platform itself has two sprinklings of plants in two colourful flower beds by a bench seat…

… either side of the shelter, also with a bench/perch seat.

This makes for a pleasant atmosphere to wait for the train and ponder what the cabinets…

… and lockers contain at the eastern end of the platform.

As you can see there’s a dot matrix display – very helpful as mobile phone signals are not good in this area – and there’s a helpful route diagram on display.

Despite the main A818 road, Sinclair Street, passing over the eastern end of the platform…

… it’s a very quiet spot to wait and ponder the lovely journey that awaits you as the train can be seen coming from quite a distance.

Delightful.

A lovely pair of stations.

Roger French

Did you catch the 14 previous blogs in this series? 1: Hertford; 2: Canterbury. 3: Wigan, 4 Dorchester, 5 Windsor, 6 Wakefield, 7 Reddish, 8 Yeovil, 9 Newark-on-Trent, 10 New Mills, 11 Tyndrum, 12 St Albans, 13 Falkirk, 14 Catford.

Summer blogging timetable 06:00 TThSSu

34 thoughts on “25 Places with two stations: 15 Helensburgh

  1. Kudos for walking UP the hill … it’s a long old pull !!! I only walked down the hill … and a delightful road, with old trees and lovely houses.

    Real Time Trains shows that (at Central) all three platforms are used in the AM peak, although I agree that they could (just) manage with one …. although I reckon that two trains are stabled there overnight

    A delightful town to explore and overnight in …. like Glasgow, built to a box grid system. Lovely!

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Your mention of Balloch reminds me of my days, long ago, of being a All Line Rail Rover ticket holder. Balloch was one of those “what if” situations. The ticket was available for travel on the Loch Lomond steamer (Maid of The Loch) but it would have taken a full five hours to do justice to the loch with few opportunities to visit the calling points for any length of time. I chose instead a more entertaining CalMac trip, this time at sea. Down from Glasgow to Ardrossan then to Brodick with a sea cruise to Campbeltown then back to Wemyss Bay. The latter place having a superb station building. This was greater mileage, and I had an hour ashore at Campbeltown too. This was all cutting edge stuff using that Rover on CalMac services.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I discovered Wemyss Bay station thanks to having bought Simon Jenkins book ‘Britain’s 100 Best Railway Stations’. My wife & I took an excursion there in 2019 & so glad we did. Apart from the wonderful architecture it was adorned with flower displays & clearly well looked after. My lasting memory was the bronze statue of a little boy carrying a toy yacht whilst heading in the direction of the ferry. You also mentioned Balloch which we also visited to cruise Loch Lomond. Our boat passed the ‘Maid of the Loch’ moored up & looking somewhat forlorn. I’m sure that it would’ve been a pleasure to travel in back in the day. Sadly, we missed Helensburgh on that occasion.

      Like

    2. The small town of Pontefract in West Yorkshire has 3 stations. Pontefract Baghill, Pontefract Monkhill, and Pontefract Tanshelf.

      There are also technical 2 stations in Castleford. Castleford, and Glasshoughton.

      Like

  3. It went through my mind, actually during the re-building on Birmingham New Street, just what Railway infrastructure must actually cost. Knowing what it costs just to maintain an ordinary house, I often wonder when I see even modest alterations going on at stations such as toilet and ticket office refurbishment taking place.

    Helensburgh Central is a typical example of a long standing building which must need constant attention, replicated throughout the system. Whilst we often complain regarding the massive subsidies for rail compared to the pittance dished out to the bus industry, I suspect a large percentage is for infrastructure rather than operation.

    In past and more dedicated days, it was not unknown for station staff to actually do small running repairs including even painting at quieter stations, but I imagine that has long stopped.

    Terence Uden

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Until 1968 Helensburgh Upper was a crossing loop, though you’d be hard put to detect it now. The station has been unstaffed since then.

    Like

    1. It had two lines until into the 80’s. And I recall only too well the station building which was staffed in the 80‘s too. The second line and building were removed either very late 80’s on very early 90’s.

      Like

  5. Would have thought those using Upper are going West towards Oban, the WHL, or the sleeper, were as thouse going to Glasgow/Edinburgh would use Central with better trains, & frequency, as Upper is on a diesel line with the trains elderly DMU class 156s, or the loco hauled sleeper, were as Central is electrified & use EMU class 334s

    SM

    Like

    1. Well if you live closer to Upper and you need a train to Glasgow at the time it’s meant to come, why would you give yourself a longer walk

      Parking also easier at Upper

      Like

  6. clydebank is a town on the Helensburgh and baloch lines and is served by no less than five working stations. Dalmuir, singer, drumry, yoker, and clydebank.

    Like

    1. Yoker is up for debate, I would have termed it as Glasgow (which Wikipedia also says) but the station is just inside West Dunbartonshire. The Mill Road overpass appears to be the boundary.

      Like

  7. The arrangement looks ideal for modellers of railways with two different stations and lines for any time period

    Rail Station maintenance in theory was often designed to be paid for in part by the “fixed min” cost of a passenger ticket – with a rate per mile to pay for trains , and of course in freight days that would contribute too along with parcels, but also the rents of commerical units – offices and retail would bring in the greatest contributing revenue. Nowadays stations have the better potential for specific grants for refurbishment as they can significantly contribute to any improved townscape (eg Huddersfield) and a pull for other investment in these days when traditional towns are under threat from the demographic and retail challenges of the present times.

    Well designed – mainly of older styles of buildings – just look right , trying to build new stations only for boarding and interchange functionality loses the integration into the whole – Brent Cross West being something that at least tries but could have been done better , likewise on new stations on reopened routes – Northumberland and Bristol Area ( and the wonderful Barry Docks but that is more for bus stations – to which similar could apply )

    JBC Prestatyn

    Like

  8. What beautiful stations, thanks. According to Wikipedia Craigendoran station used to have 5 platforms, two on each of the through lines and one for the pier! Needless to say the whole situation was rationalised in the 60s and 70s. The 1:25,000 OS map shows the current arrangement.

    Like

  9. It is an absolute joy to read your regular “blogs”. Whilst the pictures are excellent it is the wonderful commentary given from a professional point of view but very much with your “tongue in your cheek” comments that is truly the icing on the cake. I do have your book which I got signed by you and whenever I see Brighton & Hove buses (I live opposite Chichester Railway station) I think of all the good work that you achieved there. My VERY best WISHES for a continued happy retirement (I am 83 now!!)………………….a fellow Roger (Keyworth). My E-Mail address is my name, reversed on gmail.com.

    Like

  10. lovely to see Helensburgh featured in thi series as I assumed it might at some point. If you’d walked further up Sinclair Street for about 5 minutes you’d have passed my grandparents’ house, almost on the corner of the road – Dhuhill Drive? – along to the Hill House (always worth a visit). Keep blogging Roger, it’s appreciated. Cheers, John McK.

    Liked by 1 person

  11. I did wonder when Helensburgh would feature. One item missed at Helensburgh Central is the electronic display listing bus departures from the stops outside and the booking office does use both windows on occassions. It is notable that one of Scotrail’s major fare promotions, Kids for a Quid, can only be bought at a ticket office or on the train. As for overall numbers the SPT Zonecard was a popular ticket choice for many when I commuted, not sure how popular it is today but keeping track of numbers using that method must make any predictions on usage a bit variable even allowing for annual surveys etc.

    Trains do stay there overnight and there is some swapping around during the day. As you note these days the trains arrive and normally work the next train out. This hasn’t always been the case as before the Airdrie Bathgate link was restored the trains would overlap by one departure meaning it was easier to manage delays. Not so easy now and has been known to result in station skipping at Craigendoran and Cardross to make up time. The station has had quite a bit of work over the past few years, the roof was re-glazed and a section of the wall on the street side was replaced, although it hasn’t really been maintained and is now suffering due to invasive plants.

    Impressed you made Upper in 15 minutes! Not immediately obvious is the recent platform extension at the North end, this is to allow 7 coach trains to stop here. These are those which serve Oban, Fort William and Mallaig including an Explorer unit (when they are working). The next stop along at Garelochhead has also been extended. Unfortunately not possible at Dalmuir so those services no longer stop there. Until recently there was a Caledonian Sleeper electronic information point on the platform but these have been removed network wide. Helensburgh Upper is also notable in being the transition point between conventional signalling and the RETB system used on the remainder of the WHL. There is a level of commuter traffic, although I don’t know just how much these days. The first southbound train in the morning from Oban actually makes additional stops at Cardross, Singer and a couple along the Maryhill line to accommodate this.

    Bus services aren’t too bad around here either, if you ever decide to come back…

    Andrew

    Liked by 1 person

  12. Always love visiting Helensburgh using Central travelling along the northern shore of the Clyde by Scotrail from Glasgow best seen at sunset.

    Served by smart trains as part of the nation’s network with “how am I looking today” messages to encourage feedback from passengers to keep them in tip top condition.

    It was a great pity that Scotrails experiment having off peak fares all day wasn’t successful.

    John Nicholas

    Like

  13. Ambience, with an e.

    When the ticket office at Central is closed, does the machine allow full or part (presumably depending on the cost of the rail ticket) repayment of the car parking charge?

    Like

    1. Thanks for spotting the typo – now corrected. I’m not sure about the TVM – usually these days it’s only through an app or phone line that parking can be paid for.

      Like

  14. Mention of Craigendoran reminds me of my holidays on the Clyde steamers back in the 1950s.  I went with my parents to Rothesay in 1955 and 1956, and we took a weekly runabout ticket on the Clyde steamers where there was a weekly schedule of steamer excursions going to various places on the Firth of Clyde – including Ayr, Campbelltown and Inverary.  One of these was a trip twice week going via Dunoon to Lochgoilhead and Arrochar on Loch Long and return, possibly on the Waverley.  At Arrochar you could walk the couple of miles over the hill to Tarbet where the Maid of the Loch was waiting at the pier on Loch Lomond.  This boat sailed south to Balloch Pier where a train took passengers from the pier station (now closed) direct to Craigendoran Pier via Dumbarton (reversal – loco run-round) to connect with the regular ferry to Gourock.  From there the regular steamers were used to return passengers back to Dunoon and Rothesay.  As a ten year old lad I liked to go down into the engine room to watch the huge pistons driving the paddles – my parents preferred to be on deck to soak up the marvellous scenery.   A magical experience!  

    Alan N  

    Like

  15. I’ll be interested when you post an article on Bicester North abd Bicester Village stations!

    Like

  16. Parking £3 per day … much of England is double or more even arriving weekdays after say 10:00 and at weekends. To then get a full or part rebate against a rail ticket widens the gap further.

    I fully understand a high charge for non-rail users so they park elsewhere but is there anywhere in England where the parking charge is significantly reduced with proof of rail travel?

    Like

  17. Always an interest to see things about my hometown.

    To the author of the piece, thank you. You might want to look at what was in the area beside Helensburgh Central in the steam days – the are currently used by the CoOp and Doctors Surgery. There were a LOT of sidings, repair shops and a whole host of things for locomotives. The Helensburgh Central area was a lot busier than just the station….

    Like

  18. I’ve enjoyed reading about the towns you’ve included so far and realise how few of the places where I’ve visited both, even if I’ve been there.

    It made me wonder – how many towns (not big cities) have two bus stations? Matlock might be small but has two, fully functioning bus stations served by the same companies, not rivals.

    Like

Comments are closed.

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑