Thursday 22nd August 2024

In DRT news ……. following last month’s blog about NottsBus On Demand expanding into West Rushcliffe comes the long awaited new scheme in Buckinghamshire.
I paid a visit to Aylesbury on Tuesday to check out the town’s new Village Connect branded operation which began on Monday.

There have obviously been issues with this DRT’s introduction as it was one of the 19 schemes which received funding (to the tune of £1,114,000) from the DfT’s Rural Mobility Fund (RMF) back in March 2021. Many of those schemes have been up and running for a long time and indeed are nearing the end of their three year funding deal while Buckinghamshire’s other scheme in High Wycombe (PickMeUp) launched as far back as September 2022 with £736,000 funding.
A press release issued by Buckinghamshire Council in December 2023 confirmed Aylesbury’s scheme “is planned to start during the spring of 2024 and will benefit residents in villages around Aylesbury by providing another travel option to supplement existing public transport services.”

Like in High Wycombe, the scheme has been overlaid on top of the town’s bus network but, as its Village Connect brand name implies, the Aylesbury newcomer’s geographic reach extends to villages immediately outside the urban area albeit many of them are also served by inter-urban routes such as Aston Clinton and Hartwell.

It’s been contracted to WeMove with PADAM software but it’s not clear who the actual PCV ‘O licence’ operator is. Gary, my driver on Tuesday, is an agency driver so wasn’t employed directly by the operator. The address shown on the back of the three Mercedes minibuses being used on the scheme is a farm in Northwood, 30 miles from Aylesbury….

… so stretching it a bit to call it the “Local depot” as stated on the bus.

The website address, also displayed on the vehicle, through which bookings can be made doesn’t have a very memorable url and although there’s mention of an app, this isn’t yet available with the link from the information page about the service on Buckinghamshire’s website inactive (at the time of writing).

When I asked Gary if there were any printed leaflets available to promote the service he explained they weren’t ready in time and thought they might be available by the end of the week.
You’d think having been awarded the funding almost three and a half years ago and the subsequent much delayed introduction would mean these basic ingredients of a launch would have been sorted in time.

No wonder I was Gary’s first passenger of the day at 11:30 on Tuesday when he picked me up at Stoke Mandeville railway station.
I’d booked the previous evening (Monday) using the “online booking portal” for a departure at midday and was deliberately pessimistic about train connections across London…

… which in the event worked well so,having arrived in Marylebone earlier than anticipated, I rang the booking number manned by WeMove (I assume) and after a long pause (“could you hold the line please”) the lady answering rebooked me at the rather precise departure time of 11:31.

Which smacks of an AI derived time; where would we be without AI eh? Had I been told 11:30 I’d have had to wait a whole minute for the bus to arrive. But it was a load of rubbish of course because, as said, I was Gary’s first passenger and he arrived at 11:22 anyway, just as I was coming out of the station.

I’d booked a ride over to the village of Hulcott – a journey not possible on the current network without changing buses or taking a train and bus and a walk, but I actually alighted on the main A418 in Bierton before reaching the village so it was easier to catch a bus back into Aylesbury (route 100 as it happens).
While in Aylesbury, I tried booking other journeys, and obviously with three vehicles hanging around on the scheme and minuscule awareness among the public that the new service has commenced, it was easy to have any journey requests fulfilled including journeys which could easily be made on existing bus routes, which strikes me as odd, although the statement “another travel option to supplement existing public transport services” rather confirms this approach.
Why would Buckinghamshire Council want to undermine the existing network with three publicly funded minibuses which, once the RMF runs out in three years time at the end of the “pilot”, will have to cease?
Odd. But nothing about DRT ever makes sense.

Village Connect operates between 06:00 and 19:00 on Monday to Friday only – tough luck if you want to go to a village on a Saturday – with fares from £2.50 to £4.50 depending on distance travelled. My journey would have been £4.50 had I not had a concessionary pass which is valid after 09:00 although Gary was unable to record my pass on the machine as apparently that hasn’t been sorted yet either.

The news yesterday stated “Rachel Reeves is planning to raise taxes, cut spending and get tough on benefits in October’s budget ….. insisting she will still have a substantial black hole to fill”. Here’s £1,114,000 about to go down that black hole in another irresponsible and scandalous waste of public money by local authority officers and DfT civil servants who should know better. Has nothing been learnt from the DRT failures over the last five years in Bristol, Sittingbourne, Liverpool, Oxford, Ealing, Sutton, Aberdeenshire, North Yorkshire, Watford, East Leeds, Leicester and Berwickshire?
Buckinghamshire’s web page about the new service concludes “Village Connect is supported by Buckinghamshire Council and the Government’s Rural Mobility Fund and operated by transport specialists, We Move”. Interestingly the bus I travelled on had no legal lettering displayed to confirm ownership. Is that legal? The mystery operator.

Roger French
Blogging timetable: 06:00 TThS with Summer Su extras.
Comments on today’s blog are welcome but please keep them relevant to the blog topic, avoid personal insults and add your name (or an identifier). Thank you.

Looks like https://wemove.io/ who are behind the West Midlands Bus On-Demand, Westlink (West of England) and Flexibus (East Sussex) scheme.
DRH
LikeLike
Incidentally, Flexibus, launched with ten zones has now become a one-zone operation.
DRH
LikeLike
In spite of all the evidence that DRT does not work and is very expensive and does not even meet most passengers needs they continue to roll these schemes out and somehow seem to think if they keep carrying on they will get a different result
Most DRT schemes end up initially being cut back to try to reduce costs before finally being axed when the funding runs out
Hard data on DRT is hard to come by but all the indication are that the failure rate of this schemes is running at over 70%
LikeLiked by 1 person
It looks like Bucks CC had the funding, but couldn’t decide where to use it . . . perhaps they picked Aylesbury as being a town without a comprehensive town bus network.
Or maybe they decided on Aylesbury because it is the County town? Or maybe they were desperate to use the funding before it ran out? Or am I just being unkind?
Anyway . . . another waste of money, whichever way you look at it, I wonder what the eventual spend on DRT will be . . . and what it might have otherwise paid for . . . another year of the £2 fare cap?
LikeLike
After so many DRT scheme failures, you’d think someone at the DfT would say ‘Hang on, let’s review DRT operations…’, but no, let keep throwing money at abject failures.
It appears no more than a very expensive Uber/Bolt operation find in an amateurish and half-hearted way.
Have you calculated the total amount wasted on failed schemes?
LikeLiked by 1 person
About £100 million (including some private investment and Section 106 monies but mostly public funding).
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Roger – I’m just curious – as a comparison against this figure, how much per annum has the “two-pound” scheme cost in subsidy? Do you know by any chance? CH, Oxford
LikeLike
About £50 million per month according to an earlier comment (greenline727)
LikeLike
I looked in vain for a published total cost of DRT schemes in the UK, and failed. Your £100m sounds very credible – is it an educated guess, or have you succeeded where I failed, and have found a published source? If so, could you share it?
LikeLike
Just an educated guess from adding up various amounts that have been in the public domain.
LikeLike
I just hope DRT does not come to my local rural route the 165 in Devon the current timings fit reasonably with my shifts at Staverton on the SDR, I certainly could not rely on DRT to either get me there on time or pick me up afterwards asking for a 1655 pick up on the way back and being offered 1630 would be useless as 1630 is before the departure of the last train to Buckfastleigh.
LikeLike
https://www.cpt-uk.org/news/cpt-responds-150-million-funding-boost-for-local-bus-services-as-fare-cap-set-to-be-extended/
This reported that the total spend on the £2 fare cap would be around £600m over the two years January 2023 – December 2024; this was partially funded by the cancellation of HS2 north of Handsacre Junction.
So the DRT monies would’ve paid for about 2 months of the £2 fare cap. which would’ve benefitted many millions of passengers more than DRT ever would.
Just saying . . .
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yep, that is exactly the calculation I was hoping someone would make.
CH, Oxford
LikeLike
A search of the OTC licencing database for businesses with an operating centre at Ducks Hill Farm, HA6 2SP brings up the following:
PK2048012 MOVE4WORLD LTD – 4 disks;
PK2007140 HARROW MINIBUS & COACH HIRE LIMITED – 4 disks;
PK2064112 EROS CARRIAGE LIMITED – 2 disks;
so it is possibly one of those businesses?
RD
LikeLike
Looking at the bus registration search facility it’s MOVE4WORLD operating it
Bus registration details
LikeLike
Great minds, think alike. I had a look there too.
The wholesale waste of public funds on these schemes is truly appalling, and congratulations to Roger in consistently and continually highlighting the folly of such schemes. This is nothing more that Emperors New Clothes from the tech companies, and allowing hard pressed local authorities to draw on ill directed funds to allow rural services (and their attendant subsidies) to be withdrawn.
I know of one larger scheme where despite the sheer number of vehicles involved, the revenue is insufficient in covering the admin function, let alone the direct operational costs.
However, perhaps the new Labour administration will seek to undo this mess, and perhaps there are signs (unrelated to the election) that DRT is on the wane? We’ve seen Fflecsi be replaced (in part) with timetabled services in Wales whilst in West of England Combined Authority, the WestLink scheme has been so “successful” that the zones have had to be altered AND a number of new rural bus services (re)introduced. Perhaps when Roger is next in the West Country, he might want to sample the new P1, 99, recently introduced 2V and expanded X91, bringing timetabled bus services to many areas that had lost them just over a year ago?
Yours
An anonymous senior commercial manager
LikeLiked by 1 person
When I was at Solent Blue Line, I proposed to the County Council, and received funding for a network of timetabled services to plug gaps in the main network using a small bus between school runs. Some sections ran daily, Monday to Friday, others on one or two days. It operated 52 weeks a year and was a registered local bus service so normal fares and concessions applied. It seemed to work well and was economical to provide. When I moved to the County, we extended Taxi-share services using taxis, private hire vehicles or small minibuses to cover 70 communities. Again a timetabled service was offered but journeys only ran when booked through the operator. Bus-like fares applied and concessions were accepted. From memory around 25,000 trips were made annually from areas which otherwise would have lost their public transport link at a cost of around £7 a head. There are alternatives to the current DRT model.
Peter Shelley
LikeLiked by 1 person
The only operating centre I can find for them is in Harrow
LikeLike
Roger,
Have you ever thought of doing a price/time comparison with Uber for DRT journeys you make to see the price/convenience difference especially as you only pay once for multiple travellers.
John Nicholas
Waiting in rain lured by £2 fare.
LikeLike
How much longer are they flogging this dead 🐎?
LikeLike
People should press their MPs to submit questions to the Secretary of State for Transport asking how she can possibly justify the DfT continuing to waste money on these vanity schemes while curbing or cutting spending on other transport projects. Graham L.
LikeLike
It is a slightly odd scheme in that the areas shown on the map in grey as P/U or destination points are quite specific unlike the Pick Me Up in High Wycombe which doesn’t seem to have any constraints and competes with buses and taxis. Most of these areas have lost bus services over the years such as Halton Village (was on route 366 then 56) although Hulcot has never had a bus to my knowledge! One point Stoke Mandeville Post office Eskdale Road is between the A413 and the B4449 Is actually on the A4010 and has been sporadically served by Tiger Line then Arriva route 55 (laterly Red Rose) before “suspension” in Dec 2022 due to driver shortage. The community in this area has long requested a restoration. I think that these places now urgently need to know that the Connection has commenced and it may generate some trade. Alternative the option of fixed times from each location at mornings / afternoon but with a DAR operation in between might be preferable. Wendover already has a “community bus” which will go to some of the areas covered. All this is funded for three years!! John Wood – Wendover
LikeLike
I wonder if all the vehicles involved go back to the operating centre at Ducks Hill Farm?
If not, and bearing in mind the driver did not seem to know who employed him, although I think there is an O disc displayed, in wonder how legal this operation is.
LikeLike
An operating centre or OC is an important part of a coach and bus transport business and one that has to be defined in law. Vehicles are required to return to an operating centre and to be ‘normally kept’ there, as defined in the operator licence, allowing the Transport Manager to effectively manage both vehicles and drivers.
LikeLike
🤣💞
LikeLike
Valuable journalism, thank you. The previous transport secretary, Harper, wouldn’t know what a bus was if it ran him over but Louise Haigh must surely be better informed. There must be at least one official in the Daft who reads this blog and can blow the whistle on the thoughtless waste of money DRT represents in the current ‘taxi-lite’ formats used.
MikeC
LikeLike