Tuesday 2nd July 2024

Hot on the heels of the much delayed commencement of trams running to Blackpool North railway station, comes another “At last” transport development: the long awaited, much anticipated, opening of Cardiff’s new Bus Interchange on Sunday.

The Welsh capital’s former bus station closed in 2015 to make way for a smart new office development occupied by BBC Wales in the city’s prime Central Square, right in front of Cardiff Central railway station.

The replacement facility has been mired in controversy right back to the era when there was no majority control of the City Council and the minority ruling LibDems scotched the idea completely to save money. Such was the public outcry, when Labour took back control of the Council, it pledged a replacement with plans set in place for an opening in 2017, then 2019, then definitely by the end of 2023 and now, finally, seven years late and nine years without one, the sparkly new Bus Interchange finally opened for business on Sunday.

Another factor during this turbulent period has been Cardiff City Council ceding control of the project to Transport for Wales (TfW) which in recent years has overseen its delivery and now has operational control.
The new Bus Interchange has been built as part of an extensive development featuring offices, apartments and retail units situated just to the east of the former bus station’s location, still conveniently close to Central Station with pedestrian access from Central Square, but, as reported in a recent blog, comes with only 14 drive on/reverse off stands compared to the former bus station’s 34 drive through stand capacity.

However, what it lacks in capacity, it definitely makes up for in providing modern and pleasant facilities for passengers.

There are two large wall mounted electronic displays showing upcoming bus and rail departures (obviously bilingual) …

… and although Cardiff Bus doesn’t have a travel shop in the Interchange, it was good to see a display of its attractive timetable booklets and network map which used to be available at Central Station…

… but, even better, after my visit, yesterday afternoon Cardiff Bus installed another display.

Electronic displays also suspend down from the roof as you enter showing bus departures…

… and, on the reverse, as you leave, they show rail departures from the station.

Each departure bay has an electronic sign above the door showing departures – doors only open if a bus is on the stand.

There aren’t any wall mounted printed timetables or diagrams showing what service departs from where, but the electronic signs are very clear to read and show departure stands and the aforementioned timetable booklets are available – although these were printed prior to the Bus Interchange coming on stream so are not up to date in that respect. There were plenty of TfW staff on hand to help passengers when I visited yesterday late morning and across lunch time.
Readers may recall I was unsure when I peered through the doors a couple of weeks ago whether there were seats, in addition to perch style benches, so I’m pleased to report that there are including some small round tables for coffee etc.

They were also being used to distribute an A5 size flyer detailing from where services are departing.

There are free to use gender neutral toilet cubicles (including an accessible one) which will hopefully be respected by the public…


… and TfW are employing two security guards one of whom patrols around the site and the other is monitoring cctv cameras in a control room.

Indeed TfW have some smart operational offices on a mezzanine floor above one of the retail units where staff involved in rail are also now based.

TfW has also provided some rather nice facilities for bus drivers on the ground floor including a rest room with catering facilities (even including fresh milk in the fridge)…

…and toilets for staff.

There’s also a multi purpose room which could be used by a mother wishing to breast feed a child in private as well as first aid facilities…

…and there’s a very well equipped Changing Places room on the concourse.

You may also have spotted two water fountains in the photographs and extensive recycling bins (not quite up to seven bins though!).

The five retail units aren’t yet occupied but Asda and Starbucks are lined up to take the two units facing the concourse.

Tenants for the other two units, including a large one by the main entrance, are still being sought.

A decision was taken to build utilisation of the new Bus Interchange up gradually to allow for a smooth transition which is why, to kick things off this week, only 11 of the 14 departure bays are in use.
TfW has stated “there are plans for additional services to use the bus interchange later in the year, with the next phase of services expected to run from September.”

For now, Stagecoach has switched its half hourly route 122 to Tonypandy and hourly route 124 to Maerdy from Greyfriars Road to use stands 1 and 2 respectively and Cardiff Bus has moved in 11 of its services: 13 (half hourly to Ely and Drope); 25 (half hourly to Llandaff/Whitchurch); 32 (hourly to St Fagans); 61 (every 15 minutes to Pebtrebane); 62/63 (half hourly to Llandaff and Rhydlarfar or Radyr); 92/93/94 (every 10 minutes to Penarth then Dinas Powys/Sully/Barry); 95 (half hourly to Llandough and Barry); and 96 (half hourly to Wenvoe and Barry).

That makes for 24 buses an hour, and watching the arrivals and departures yesterday, it came across as a sensible opening gambit especially as Cardiff Bus drivers get used to reversing off stands – something they’ve not done previously.

Traffic light phasing at the north end of Great Western Lane – where most buses enter and exit the Interchange – may need careful monitoring when more departures are added to ensure there’s sufficient capacity across the junction without tail backs into the Interchange.

Pedestrians who’ve been used to walking along Great Western Lane as a cut through are now met with a shock as security personnel are being deployed to stop any access at both ends of the Lane for fear passengers would use it as a way to access the Interchange which would entail a dangerous walk across the bus manoeuvring area.


I suspect proper barriers will have to be erected to make this a permanent arrangement.

With the Bus Interchange operating below its ultimate capacity the area of the concourse where passengers queue for departures from each stand won’t yet be fully tested but it looked like it could be a bit tight at busy times if people queue back from the door in a straight line.

However the area in front of each departure stand is nice and open offering flexibility of where passengers can wait, albeit not in a strict queue formation.

As you can see it’s a very attractive facility and a huge improvement on what was a dated facility past its prime in the old bus station. TfW has done well to fit in as much as it has in the limited space and create an airy and pleasant place to catch a bus.
After all this time it makes sense to phase in the bus routes that are going to use the Bus Interchange rather than go for a big bang approach, as this enables staff to get used to it, operational teething issues to be sorted out and passengers to become familiar with the facilities.
Cardiff Bus have plans to bring more services into the Interchange in September, albeit the most frequent cross city routes will remain outside but, the big issue is there are no plans for Stagecoach to relocate its other long distance routes into the Bus Interchange including TrawsCymru routes T4 (Merthyr Tydfil, Brecon, Llandrindod Wells and Newton) and T14 (Merthyr Tydfil, Brecon, Hay-on-Wye and Hereford) including additional half hourly journeys as far as Merthyr Tydfil.
These routes will continue to terminate in Greyfriars Road on the northern edge of the city’s central area, which Google reckons is a 15 minute walk from Central Station. Hardly helpful for “seamless interchange” if someone arrives by train and wants to travel onwards to, say, Brecon or Hay-on-Wye.

I understand extending these routes into the Bus Interchange will cost additional resources because of the distance involved and hence Stagecoach’s reluctance. But that also indicates how much passengers are going to be inconvenienced too. TfW, which oversees and supports the TrawsCymru network, needs to find a solution to this as quickly as possible.
In the PR blurb about the new Bus Interchange, TfW reckons it will “offer better connections to and between different transport modes including bus, rail, walking, cycling and wheeling”. It adds: “the Interchange is part of our wider plan for ‘Metro Central’, an integrated transport hub that allows easy use and access to all modes of public transport on a ‘turn up and go’ basis in the heart of Cardiff”.
It needs to add… “…except for TrawsCymru”.

My thanks to both Gareth at Cardiff Bus and Gavin at TfW who I randomly met separately during my visit yesterday and kindly showed me round.

Roger French
Blogging timetable: 06:00 TThS with Summer Su extras including this Sunday.
Comments on today’s blog are welcome but please keep them relevant to the blog topic, avoid personal insults and add your name (or an identifier). Thank you.

The recycling bins follow current Welsh Government legislation for all businesses, in force since April. Even my church’s kitchen has to have a similar arrangement!
Coach services (NE, Megabus, Flixbus) will continue to operate from “elsewhere”, too.
Andrew Kleissner
LikeLike
First Cymru appear not to be using he bus station nor Edwards
LikeLike
What is most funny is that the First Cymru services into Cardiff are all tenders as well! Granted tenders by other authorities but they are tenders nevertheless.
Edwards 400 I doubt will extend as it’s commercial and would need an extra bus to extend.
LikeLike
Edwards only have 1 bus, the 400 and that never went from the old bus station. It’s a shame that First’s X2 and 304 are not operating from there and they would only take up 3 departures an hour.
LikeLike
Looking at the T4/T14 timetables, I’d guess you’re looking at an extra bus and at least two driver shifts per day to cover the extension into the bus station, so it won’t be cheap.
I’m also not sure the demand is there for connections off GWR at Cardiff to Brecon. The journey planners route people coming from England via Abergavenny and then the 43/X43 bus which is a quicker and more frequent service than the T4.
LikeLike
Digging a bit deeper into the T4/T14 scenario . . . the bus and train both take around 60 minutes from Cardiff to Merthyr; both run every 30 minutes. The new bus station at Merthyr is about a three minute walk from the rail station. I’d estimate an extra 10 minutes each way to extend to the new Bus Station in Cardiff, so the train might be marginally faster.
I’ve lost track of train frequencies on the CVL network, but was Merthyr going to see 4 TPH??
With forthcoming full integration between bus and train (teehee) . . . and also through ticketing (chuckle) . . . I’d suggest that the long-term will see passengers routed train > bus . . . and I doubt that there are a huge number of passengers from north of Merthyr to Cardiff.
LikeLike
Yes, Merthyr trains will be 4/hr from next year
LikeLike
After sone digging around I found a map with details of where all the buses are stopping in Cardiff , It does not include any express service etc as far as I can tell
Cardiff Bus Interchange – Cardiff Bus
At the bottom of the service list table is a link to it
LikeLike
As Greenline727 states, there has to be a question mark over the T4/T14 when the South Wales Metro comes to fruition. The former X4 enjoyed a significant frequency advantage over rail from Pontypridd and Merthyr but that has been eroded and will disappear in time.
It looks like a decent facility and some credit to the local authority and TfW for making the best out of a situation that should never have happened (thanks to a previous administration).
BW2
LikeLike
Tuesday 2nd July 2004.………….
Back in the good days tho!
LikeLike
Almost when t should have opened!
LikeLike
Good thing TrawsCymru isn’t considered complementary to the rail network then. That’s probably why when I tried to travel from St Davids to Cardiff recently the now very infrequent T11 from St Davids misses the two-hourly rail service at Haverfordwest, to Carmarthen/Swansea/Cardiff/Newport and other places on the way to that well-known Welsh city, Manceinon, by three minutes.
LikeLike
Much missed the rather nice (External) design of the old bus station block (but cold to work in in winter), the number of local and longer distance services needed the old arrangement , but indeed it had become dated. I never understood the geography of Cardiff, nor how journeys across and into it were best completed. In some ways the centre of Cardiff – for many passengers – has changed and a central gathering place for (All) bus services become less relevant. Bus vs Rail – we were talking about that in the 1980s and bus should actually be cheaper for passengers if rail got full costing.
JBC Prestatyn
Off topic https://www.msn.com/en-gb/cars/news/london-bus-route-labelled-awful-as-6-out-of-7-single-deckers-taken-off-road/ar-BB1p9yxZ can you do a verify on this, it appears Sullivan Buses seem to be having problems, at one time in the pre-degregulation days if an operator having the registered service had some problems other companies (as the couldnt compete) would help out with hiring vehicles or staff(if avalible)
LikeLike
Sullivan Buses have been in difficulties recently, and are steadily withdrawing from TfL work. Like all operators in London, recruiting and retaining staff is challenging and, despite the wishes of TfL, pretty much all operators are reliant on agency drivers, some garages to a greater extent than others.
Sullivan’s is probably the last of the SME London operators . . . the rest have either sold out to the bigger groups or closed. A good illustration of the trials and tribulations of London bus work . . . without deep pockets, investment in hybrid or electric buses isn’t possible, and that is what TfL require in the future.
This MyLondon report is actually reasonably fair . . . in the past their reporting has been noted as somewhat biased, but not so here.
LikeLike
Sullivans are giving up or have lost the contracts for several minor TfL routes
LikeLike
A bunch of Sullivan’s school buses loses have been to Uno, who I think now have a PVR of 22 for TfL contracts.
LikeLike
From personal experience the 299 also a Sullivans route in north London has been abysmal of late. Clearly a systemic problem it seems. TfL must resolve it.
LikeLike
Sullivan’s are a decidedly dubious operator. A few years ago one of their buses abruptly terminated mid-journey and dumped my friend and others at the roadside with a promise that another bus would be along shortly. It failed to appear, and they had a very long wait until the next scheduled bus. Letters of complaint and requests for an explanation were ignored. Graham L.
LikeLike
Cross-city journeys in Cardiff are generally quite tortuous due to the lack of bridges across the Rhymney and Taff river. There is a plan for a new Rhymney bridge between St Mellons and Pentwyn, but will it ever happen?
Andrew Kleissner
LikeLike
NAT buses gave up their Cardiff routes due to traffic congestion
LikeLike
By NAT do you mean (New) Adventure Travel? They still operate the C1 (used to be X1) Culverhouse Cross – Pontprennau via the city centre, also a lot of the school bus services.
LikeLike
One wonders who selected the routes to use the new terminus and on what basis. The pattern in other major centres with a bus station is generally that it is used by the longer routes, and if space permits also by local services. In Cardiff however this seems to have been reversed, and I am surprised to see that not even the well-known 30 to Newport merits a place in the new facility.
Ian McNeil
LikeLike
It appears to be largely geographical, all this initial phase seems to be routes heading broadly westwards out of the city and the bus station is on the western side of the city centre but even there it isn’t all routes heading that way (including some notable longer routes heading west being omitted).
I have seen it suggested that the 30 was planned to serve so presumably will be in a later stage but on the list that someone posted the last time Roger mentioned Cardiff Bus Station that was the only eastbound service group and other than the Thornhill routes (or some of those) that were also included in that list the only one that appeared to head round the city centre on the way out.
Interestingly some of these routes didn’t serve the old bus station, the Drope (cross city) & Penarth (terminating at The Hayes which is mostly now pedestrianised but there are nearby stops) served the road outside as they passed and didn’t pull in.
Dwarfer
LikeLike
The logic here for Cardiff Bus was moving buses into the interchange which could be easily moved in. Various services here used to terminate on Wood Street, literally just outside the bus station, so logically they moved in. Other buses were buses which terminated on Westgate Street (a few minutes away) and had sufficient time to extend without basically any timetable changes.
For Stagecoach, the logic was the 122 terminated at the Philharmonic and now Cardiff Council removed the bus stops and made them into a taxi rank, Stagecoach just moved into the adjacent bus station. The 124 used to terminate at the Philharmonic and only moved to Greyfriars Road due to the disruption during the bus station construction.
LikeLike
I’m very glad to see that they have good quality public toilets because as someone who lives in Cardiff, all the decent public toilets are disappearing and lots of others require a purchase to use them.
However, there are no bins in front of the bus station on Central Square which I think is incredibly poor planning. I have raised this with TFW as I’ve been told they manage it so hopefully some will be added.
LikeLike
so what about the likes of National Express? Will they continue to use Sophia Gardens and be completely out the way of it all
LikeLike
I do hope the Stagecoach T4 and T14 Brecon/ Newtown buses will be scheduled to the new Bus Interchange. Also what about National Express?
LikeLike