Another ride on the 730/731 to Heathrow

Thursday 21st December 2023

Newbury & District (part of the Reading Buses suite of bus operations) has recently introduced three new Volvo B8R Plaxton Panther 3 coaches on the fledgling flightline branded route between Basingstoke, Frimley, Camberley, Bagshot and Heathrow Airport, so I made a return visit last Saturday to see how the route was doing and take a ride on the new coaches.

Readers may recall route 730/731 was introduced with funding from Heathrow Airport in August to provide new links between the airport and this prosperous area either side of the Surrey and Hampshire border. Aimed at staff working at Heathrow as well as airline passengers the route uses the M3/M25 when not calling at the main stops it serves along the way and terminates at Heathrow Terminal 5 where there are free to use onward connections to the other terminals.

The route was initially operated by former Weavaway/Reading Buses double decks but the dealer stock Volvo coaches have now bedded in after some initial teething issues, so four months on from launch, it was timely to take another ride.

The coaches are in a smart Best Impressions designed livery using what is now becoming the branding of choice for high profile bus routes serving Heathrow: the resurrected flightline name.

The seats are comfortable and the leg room just about adequate for the relatively short duration of the journey. There are usb sockets and seat back trays.

The seat immediately behind the front entrance steps also has a fold out tray but I’d be very wary about using the coffee cup hole or lipped ring as it didn’t look big enough and I’d be fearful the cup would go flying off with any vehicle movement.

There’s a mid ship wheelchair space with retractable lift…

… and space to store luggage at the base of the body which our driver happily leapt out of the cab to use on three occasions.

There’s a toilet half way along the coach on the offside.

The clock was eight minutes fast but that’s the only minor thing I can report, as the coaches certainly give a presence for the route and the journey was a very smooth one to enjoy too.

I caught the 10:45 from Basingstoke and the coach was already parked up on the bus stop when I arrived an hour beforehand, having been the 09:10 arrival into Basingstoke from Heathrow. At 10:40 the driver appeared in the driving seat – he must have been taking a break on board the coach – and myself and the four other waiting passengers boarded.

One travelled to Frimley, two to Bagshot and one to Heathrow. We left at 10:48 and were soon on the M3 (at 11:00) …

… coming off ten minutes later with an arrival into Frimley at 11:13, where we made a seamless transition from being a 731 to a 730 and gained a new passenger travelling to Heathrow replacing the one who alighted.

It’s odd that the next timing point is Knoll Road in Camberley …

…rather than by the railway station where we were due to depart at 11:27 – we arrived at 11:25, took four on board and left at 11:28. One of the four went to Bagshot and the other three were Heathrow bound.

We dropped the three alighters off in Bagshot spot on time at 11:37 and made our way back to the M3 joining it at 11:42, reaching the M25 junction at 11:48 and then for the first time met slow moving traffic, but luckily could soon take the slip road for the Terminal 5 exit …

… where we arrived exactly on time at midday and the five passengers on board alighted helped by the driver unloading suitcases from the luggage compartment which he’d stowed at the boarding stops.

It was an enjoyable and impressively efficient smooth journey. The six passengers paying fares (three of the nine travelling were concessions) were either charged £2 if travelling as far as Frimley or £4 if continuing on to Bagshot or Heathrow, or those boarding in Camberley all paid just £2. That’s because the route split in Frimley means the £2 maximum fare, which now applies to the route, also has to be paid twice.

From the Reading Buses/Newbury & District website

As I mentioned last time the very prominent route split arrangement used on this route/these routes is a very annoying bureaucratic anachronism which in these post Brexit “take back control” times really does need sorting out.

It’s unnecessarily confusing for passengers, especially when the departure times listed at the bus stop in Basingstoke emphasise Frimley as the prominent destination with Heathrow only in smaller print…

… with the opposite the case at Heathrow Terminal 5.

Come on DfT sort this out and allow bus companies to register routes such as this as one rather than split into two (to avoid coming under more draconian EU style driving hours regulations and tachograph use). The whole thing is a nonsense.

It looks as though the three new coaches are now providing a reliable and consistent service which will no doubt help raise the profile of the route. Although I did spot one of Newbury & District’s three plain liveried Volvos which are used as a back up out on one of the three vehicle workings on Saturday.

Numbers travelling are obviously still small but it takes longer than four months to build a new airport service, especially in the off season, but all the time Heathrow Airport are putting money in to support the route, it’s good for public transport.

After alighting in Heathrow Terminal 5 I thought I’d catch a free to use Piccadilly or Elizabeth line/Heathrow Express train the one stop to Terminals 2/3.

My goodness, what a palaver that was. I got to the Piccadilly line platform where there should be a 10 minute frequency only to find a huge crowd waiting and no information about the time of the next train on display. A member of staff told me it would be about 15-20 minutes. I decided to go to the Elizabeth line/Heathrow Express platform – which is a long route march up lifts and down again taking about five minutes – only to see the next train wasn’t for 20 minutes. I took the route march back to the Piccadilly line and eventually boarded a packed train which sat in the platform for 10 minutes before leaving. It took just over half an hour to make the one stop journey and wasn’t an impressive experience for arriving passengers from abroad.

I later saw TfL’s website advising “major delays between Heathrow Airport and Acton Town due to a shortage of serviceable trains”.

It would be very helpful if times of the next departures were displayed before passengers have to commit to one platform or the other. Alternatively I should have taken the bus. But it’s not clear for tourists which bus to take either.

Roger French

Blogging timetable: 06:00 TThS with a bonus Christmas Eve Blog Special this Su. Yes, it’ll be a Blog weekend bonanza featuring my Review of the Year, Quiz of the Year and the BusAndTrainUser Awards for 2023 with more to come on Boxing Day too.

Comments are welcome but please keep them relevant to the blog topic, avoid personal insults and add your name (or an identifier). Thank you.

24 thoughts on “Another ride on the 730/731 to Heathrow

  1. Thanks for this encouraging report: my only experience with airport-coach links was at Gatwick, where (many years ago) I caught the X11 coach – more by luck than anything else: the stop was not marked, no timetables anywhere, nor did Gatwick (who were subsidising the route) have any details at the enquiry desk! The X11 didn’t survive much longer … Hopefully Heathrow are more clued up.

    Re the rail transfers from T5, what a dreadful mess! I don’t understand the ‘Liz-line’ logic: the eastern branches (Shenfield/AbbeyWood) operate on the simple, successful hundred-year old ‘Underground’ basis of frequent, all-stations trains, but in the west it’s a typical south-London style ragbag of less-frequent, skip-stopping trains which – particularly at Heathrow – must be a nightmare for tourists. How about three all-stations service patterns: Abbey Wood-Reading/Maidenhead; Shenfield-T4; Canary Wharf (or a new City Airport station)-T5. With trains every 7/8 minutes on all of these, people will be happy to trade a short wait while changing, for the vastly greater simplicity. And the better service in the west should hopefully encourage a meaningful transfer from car to public transport.

    My suggestion for the Piccadilly line would be all trains to terminate at Heathrow – that should give decent frequencies at both T4 and T5. Give the Uxbridge branch to the District (maybe divert the Ealing Broadway trains, building a station at ‘East Ealing’ for transfers to Central (and maybe Liz line) trains. With some track work, we could have level-boarding stations from Ealing Common to Uxbridge! North of Finsbury Park, how about a Piccadilly branch over the old ‘Northern Heights’ railway? – new stations at Stroud Green and Crouch End, connections with the Northern at Finchley, and take over the Mill Hill East branch, extended to Mill Hill Broadway (Thameslink). A semi-radial, semi-peripheral routing like this has worked wonders on the Victoria Line, and would give the Piccadilly two north-eastern termini to match T4 and T5.

    Sorry – this comment has strayed a bit far from the 730-731!

    Rick Townend

    Like

    1. I doubt there is the capacity to take all the Piccadilly trains to Heathrow. I would doubt even the need to them when there are alternative fast rail links to Heathrow

      Like

  2. Most operators offer a single £2 fare across the length of a split registration route (such as the Yorkshire Coastliner Leeds to Scarborough example quoted in the government’s own publicity) so Reading Buses not doing this seems to be the anachronism. And as far as I can tell, a £4 single is not eligible for reimbursement, even if it is supposed to be 2 x £2.

    Like

    1. Is this £4 nonsense due to using different route numbers for each section I wonder?

      I’ve done a whole load of “split registration” services since the £2 date has existed, eg Weymouth-Axminster (either way), Norwich-Peterborough or Minehead-ilfracombe for example, and never been charged more than £2 for the whole trip… if so, then they only needed to give it just one number throughout and the problem would have been solved…..

      Mackay

      Like

      1. The same applied when I travelled from Skegness to Lincoln in the summer. Registration split at Horncastle and £2 for the whole journey.

        Keith Briant

        Like

      2. No, it’s not due to the different route numbers. You can travel from Skipton to Lancaster for £2 using the linked 580/582/82 services operated by Kirkby Lonsdale. Three service numbers, one bus, one fare.

        Cynical mouse that I am, I suspect it’s just a way of increasing revenue.

        A. Nony Mouse.

        Like

    2. In this case it’s not the traditional split registration. It’s two separately numbered routes, 730 and 731. That’s the absolutely watertight way of satisfying the TC and evidently allows two lots of £2 to be charged.

      Steve

      Like

      1. If you paid once on each route, I’d agree, but the description makes it sound as though it is a single £4 payment covering both registrations.

        Like

      2. If you look at the timetable it shows through tickets are issued for most journeys so it operates in most cases as a single route

        Like

    3. Aren’t the £2 cap participants paid lump sums in advance? In that scenario they would surely have already agreed the extent of route eligibility (and duration of participation) with the DfT.

      Like

    1. Reading’s other coach routes are – and on 2nd Jan the 702 will be split into two segments like the 730/731 so I don’t think Reading are minded to “fix” this problem.

      Like

      1. Only for those few journeys between Legoland and Reading and even then the timetable states £2 ANY one way ride. The main Legoland – Victoria section remains intact and unchanged.

        Steve

        Like

        1. There are some timetable changes on all or most journeys though – some are changed by a lot of minutes

          Like

  3. If the 730/731 shows signs of being successful, extending to and from Central Bus Station could make it even more attractive. I realise this would entail extra resource costs though, so for now terminating at Terminal 5 with free onward train travel is a reasonable compromise.

    Like

  4. Miss those double-deckers, which of course were much easier to board for some. New coaches at current prices do seem to be rather over the top for what is only a short distance service (for a coach route).

    I cannot believe that the former EU regulations still seem to apply….countless examples of mis-leading destinations displayed rather than the ultimate. I fear there are some Civil Servants who are unhappy with the new order post-Brexit, and many advantages of returning to a sovereign nation are simply being “over-looked”, this being one such example.

    Terence Uden

    Like

    1. For once I don’t think we can blame the civil serpents. I suspect that they’re carrying on with the existing instructions until told otherwise, and let’s face it this government doesn’t actually seem to give much of a toss about anything – and when they do, they just make themselves look incompetent.

      A. Nony Mouse

      Like

  5. Civil servants can only operate to a political will. There have been countless representations about the EU route lengths and several ministers of transport have ignored them all. There is no political will to sort this out.

    Like

  6. We all know the Civil Service “controls” Ministers rather than the other way round…..but yes, there is a lack of political will as clearly a strong Brexit supporting Minister would have sorted things out several years ago. In the case of numbering 730 and 731, the original fare scale applied as a through fare and way, way more than 2 x £2…..which makes the situation even more odd.

    Terence Uden

    Like

    1. I think we can stop the Brexit hating, civil servant conspiracy theories.

      Think about it. Given the massive issues that we are still having to implement Sanitary & Phytosanitary (SPS) measures on imports to/from the UK, micromanaging the rail industry, dealing with BSIP/BSIP+ and ZEBRA schemes, do you really think the issue of split registrations is at the forefront of some mandarins mind?

      Far bigger fish to fry!

      BW2

      Like

  7. It’s a pity the 731 routing bypasses the centre of Hook (which has a nearby business park of potential customers, residential, plus a rail interchange with no walking unlike the centre of Basingstoke) when coming onwards from Old Basing towards the M3 at J5. It really wouldn’t add a significant extra time (especially if it was pickup only towards Heathrow, and dropof towards Basingstoke, to avoid abstracting trade from Stagecoach 13).

    I have submitted a suggestion already.

    Miles Thomas

    Like

  8. Best Impressions copy and paste liveries are becoming as sterile and samey as the general bus network in the UK

    Like

Comments are closed.

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑