Saturday 9th December 2023

It’s not only Leicester City Council running a free circular bus service around the city centre with electric buses; Hereford also started giving it a go a couple of weeks ago, on 24th November, with its new City Zipper.

Operated on the City Council’s behalf by Yeomans Travel, the 15 minute frequency timetable (30 minutes on Sundays) between 08:00 and 18:16 (fewer hours at weekends) uses three brand new Yutong E9 electric buses purchased by Hereford City Council especially for the route using funding from the Stronger Towns Fund.


The Council received £22.4 million earlier this year following a successful bid to the Government’s £3.6 billion Towns Fund for fifteen “trailblazing” projects across the city including a Digital Culture Hub, an Encore Music Hub, a skatepark, a cycle track, a Digital Skills Centre along with nine other worthy escapades and the City Zipper.

I’m told operating costs for the service have confirmed funding until 2026 so plenty of time for residents and visitors to enjoy the convenience of a free sightseeing tour of this popular city as well as providing easier access to some of the key destinations in the city centre.

Hereford’s somewhat sprawling central area has always presented a bit of a challenge for access, with the railway station a 10 to 15 minute walk from the city centre and two separate locations for bus stations used by either country buses or city buses.

Strangely the new City Zipper’s route doesn’t serve the city bus station which might have something to do with not wanting to abstract passengers making short journeys on local bus routes (which I can’t see is really an issue) but it does provide a link to other destinations including the hospital, cathedral, library, theatre and half a dozen other bus stops for centrally located shops and the city’s large Asda.

I was in Hereford on Tuesday to give the route a try out from the railway station and two passengers were already on the bus when it arrived at 13:00 who alighted at the next stop at the hospital.

No one else travelled on the circuit as far as Asda where I hopped off to catch the bus behind. That arrived with one passenger on board who alighted at the library and two who’d boarded with me at Asda alighted at the theatre. The third bus had a couple on board as it passed through the station 15 minutes later. So small beginnings for numbers travelling, but if Leicester is anything to go by, as awareness increases, numbers travelling with soon increase.
The reason I did a bus change at Asda was to savour the unusual interior decor and moquette deployed on the three buses.

Each bus is named and carries a different design of apples, pears or hops which are all connected to local cider, champagne and lager making (respectively) as explained in a rather large leaflet (A3 folded to A4 size) available to pick up from a box on each bus.


It’s certainly eye catching and will surely be a talking point with those travelling for the first time.

When I posted some photos on X it drew a large number of responses across a wide range of views from the hideous to the appreciative. But the serious point was also made the design doesn’t meet accessible standards.

The flooring has also been given a makeover with a fake grass type of look.

I travelled on Green Horse followed by Pilot.

Sadly the third bus, Handsome Norman (featuring apples), was off the road due to a broken door on Tuesday and was being substituted by a standard Yeomans Travel Optare Solo which doesn’t quite have the same effect.

Three buses for a PVR of three with a journey time of 41 minutes for a circuit (including three minutes pause at Asda) makes it look a bit tight and on Sundays one bus aims to get round in half an hour providing a half hourly frequency. But, in the event, the times seemed reasonable with a few pauses as we passed around the circuit. I can imagine it might get tight if traffic builds up in Herefore which I know it can do.
My journey wasn’t initially helped by some odd traffic light phasing to exit the country bus station where a green light coincided with the road ahead being blocked by traffic queuing at the lights on the junction to the right. We eventually managed to get out on the third green cycle.

As in Leicester the buses are dual door and come with usb sockets.

There are two screens showing upcoming stops with one forward facing for anyone using the wheelchair bay.

Also as in Leicester, the Yutong interiors have a rather higgidy piggledy interior layout as you can see from the following photos.




Bus stops around the route are all designated with special plates but no timetables are displayed anywhere.

While I was at Asda an employee from the Council arrived to stick the A4 leaflet up on the shelter and I asked why it doesn’t include the timetable.

Apparently the times shown online (which are themselves not easy to find) are just a first stab and may change with operating experience, but she felt the 15 minute frequency means people may not need a timetable pointing out buses leave both the station and Asda on the hour and every 15 minutes thereafter.

Personally I think you need a ten minute frequency for a true turn-up-and-go experience with passengers needing to know first and last bus times. On Sundays the half hourly timetable is definitely not turn-up-and-go.

If you’re in Hereford any time over the next three years do take a free ride and admire some of the city’s landmark sites from a fruity seat, because I can’t see City Hopper surviving beyond its current 2026 funding deadline.

Roger French
PS: Phil Tonks has also been out on the City Zipper and blogged about his similar experience and conclusions.
Blogging timetable: 06:00 TThS.
Comments are welcome but please keep them relevant to the blog topic, avoid personal insults and add your name (or an identifier). Thank you.

The more of Roger’s BSIP reports I read, the more convinced I am that Hertfordshire has the right approach, put the money into beefing up frequencies on core routes where there are proven traffic flows and use these new routes to establish new pairings of destinations.
That seems to be the only way of building revenue to the point where the routes have a chance of surviving beyond the initial funding, although I can see some of the new rural Oxfordshire services being affordable long term if they can be provided cost-efficiently using vehicles already funded to do school runs.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Whilst a “nice to have”, this all smacks of the 1999 “Rural Bus Fund” pot of £50 million which the then Blair government threw at Councils in an attempt to be seen “doing something”. A laudable aim which seemed to take some Councils by surprise and thus most of it was totally wasted in hastily cobbled together schemes which soon died a death.
The money would have been far better spent, and have gone much further improving existing services. Why, One might ask, is the need for dual doors and thus less seating on such small vehicles? Presumably door alarms are screeching every few seconds London-style which makes for an uncomfortable journey. And unless my eyes deceive me, some of those seats in the forward section look far too low and clearly designed by people who neither travel by bus nor have arthritic knees. A common fault replicated by many railway carriages.
I would love to be proved wrong, but I think we all know what will happen in 2026, and I wonder how many Herefordshire “lifeline” services may wither and die before then due to “lack of funding”
Terence Uden
LikeLiked by 1 person
I was delighted to be invited to launch of Zipper one of the biggest initiatives in Hereford since Midland Red West pioneered deregulation with Yeomans in 1981 in the City. What has shocked me Roger is no mention that Yeomans accept payment by Andy Street CBE Swift Cards from Transport for West Midlands. Passengers in Hereford on Yeomans are able to take advantage of the same cashless system for paying for travel on thier services as in Brum. An unusual omission from you Roger of something of great benefit to bus passengers in Hereford who can use the same Swift Card in both the Cities of Hereford & Brum.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I am of course aware that Zipper is free to use !
LikeLike
Much of the money today is being thrown at DRT which are doomed to fail. The latest one to go is the Watford Click service
LikeLike
Regarding the 15 minute frequency, no timetable might just about be acceptable if it could be relied upon. But is can’t, Roger’s account records a hold up near the country bus station, add in the inconsiderate delivery drivers who must stop right outside the store they are delivering to even though it blocks traffic behind, the driver who is sure they can fit their 15-and-a-half yard van into a sixteen yard gap and will spend the next half hour proving it, or the hesitant car driver who is not certain whether there is a sufficient gap to turn right this time, or this time, or this time, maybe this time, whoops I’ve stalled, or any one of a 100 other hazards. In effect a 15 minute frequency means, that anyone just missing a bus should anticipate having to wait up to 20 minutes for the next under normal conditions. It could just be the hourly departure times, just a bit of a clue, whether the passenger has time to put the Christmas cards in the postbox, move some shopping from the heavy bad to the light bag, whatever.
LikeLike
To be attractive to users my view is frequencies need to be at minimum every 20 minutes
Rather than throw money at a £2 fare which seems to have had little impact on passenger numbers use it to increase frequencies
In England have a simple England wide zonal fare system
Say :-
0 – 3 miles £2
3 – 6 Miles £3
5-12 miles £5
Over 12 miles £7
Exact distances and fares probably need a bit more thought
LikeLike
Those prices are fine for a single traveller, but in my view prohibitive for a couple or family.
Andrew Kleissner.
LikeLike
What is an ‘Andy Street CBE Swift Card’? It must slow buses down having to ask the driver for one of those……
LikeLike
Swift is an integrated payment system similar to the Oystercard in London which has been promoted by Andy Street CBE Mayor of West Midlands Combined Authority to become the main method of payment for travel in the West Midlands which enabled passengers to travel cash free by placing the Swiftcard on the bus or tram cardreader.
LikeLike
A quick update on Herts Connect . . . Route 724 gets a new timetable from 7 January 2024, which improves drastically the interworking with new Route 725. Now that the full picture is known . . . HertsConnect looks better and better, although actual timekeeping is less than sparkling.
There are also booklets advertised on the Arriva website:
https://www.arrivabus.co.uk/latest-news/hertfordshire-network-changes-jan-24
. . . whether these are virtual booklets or actual printed versions is not yet known.
Dare I say that Arriva (and its website) might be emerging from the torpor of the last few years?
LikeLike
Last time I travelled between Hertford and Welwyn there were very few passengers except between Hatfield and Welwyn. I am not convinced a 15 minute service will work
LikeLike
We shall see, but each of the Hertford to Welwyn Garden City services will do something different with regards to intermediate timing points.
Dan Tancock
LikeLike
Yes first and last times are very important so a simple timetable going something like;0830 then every 15 minutes until 1815 would suffice.
LikeLike
I get really annoyed by the condescension of a person in power who tells me I don’t “need” a timetable if a bus runs every 15 minutes. I don’t have the time to just “turn up” and just miss a bus and waste 14 minutes twiddling my thumbs. Personally I’ll only trust “turn up and go” if it’s every 6 minutes like my local route here in London and even then I’ll use the live bus app before heading to the stop. In the late evenings I know the exact timings on my 10 minute frequency route home from the station so I know whether to walk or run up the stairs from the station. Mind you this is all thanks to the excellent londonbusroutes.net website and not unfortunately London Transport.
LikeLike
From your photos of two variants the seat back moquette is a big no from me. If the area covered was not too larger maybe OK as an external vinyl and/or for part of the trim inside. I wonder what the additional cost was too.
I note the reference to not complying with accessibility standards. Given these are brand new buses how has it not been officially picked up on?
LikeLike